If
you know exactly what you are going to do, what is the point of doing
it? Pablo
Picasso He goeth furthest who knows not whither he is going. Oliver Cromwell Every line in your calculations ends with "=0". You are not making much progress! Kate Hammett We don't do the calculation because we don't know the answer, we do it because we have a conscience. Bryan Taylor Let's change the resolution on the Unknown. Gabe Plunk Let me put it differently: suppose we had a reactor... Per Helander Working together takes more than one person. Bill Dorland We can't do ultraviolence to that square bracket. Ian Abel Field lines are forever. Bryan Taylor This is not really an ill-posed problem, this is not a problem at all. Paul Dellar I am just doing mathematics at the moment, but it is mathematics that has some point. Bryan Taylor The equivalent of God in MAST is MHD, which is global and all-powerful. Anthony Field I've got a fishbone coming up. Tim Horbury We have crossed all the i's and dotted all the t's. Job's a good'un. Ian Abel Let us not jump in front of the bandwagon! Alex Schekochihin It's not the triviality, it's the emptiness of it that bothers me. Bryan Taylor Never take 0 for an answer. Alex Schekochihin This is a very inefficient way of achieving nothing. François Rincon We Hankel all the way in and then Hankel all the way out. Joseph Parker For the sake of fairness, let me mention that some people have objections to this, none of which are particularly valid. Chris Chen Yes, Steve, you have always known what we have only just figured out. Alfred Mallet This is more or less right. Perhaps less. Alfred Mallet You go ahead with your argument. I'll think. Steve Cowley Too simple? At the end of my talk, you will beg for simplicity! Andrey Beresnyak What is the point? The point is not the point! Anonymous This is why I am presenting this here and nowhere else: nothing is solved! Ian Abel This calculation is not intellectual masturbation: there's no orgasm. Anonymous |
It is
better to be vaguely right than exactly wrong. Carveth
Read (usually attributed to Maynard Keynes) Previous studies of this problem have been either unsatisfactory or limited in scope.---What is the difference between these?---This means either wrong or irrelevant. Anatoly Spitkovsky, Michael Medvedev & Steve Cowley (in conversation) I don't give a damn about astrophysics, explain to me what is going on. Anatoly Spitkovsky Have you subtracted the baby with the bathwater? Steve Balbus This is not rigour, unless you mean rigor mortis. Ian Abel I wouldn't say these are theoretical arguments... Let's just call them arguments. François Rincon You can never be too happy with the state of your closure. Amitava Bhattacharjee For this plot, 1 is 6.--- Weeell, not even. Steve Cowley & Steve Balbus This qualitative explanation is not of sufficient quality. Eugene Churazov If you mean it seriously, this is actually a very good question. Minhyong Kim This paper is a tour de farce. Ian Abel What is modelling? You run a simulation, you compare. If it coincides, great! If it doesn't coincide, fuck! Felix Parra We are stuck at x=0. Felix Parra I have seen papers where the student wasn't the problem. Michael Hardman There has been a lot of fascinating work on this subject, most of it kind of boring. Philipp Kempski So now you want us to drop everything we are doing and start worrying about what the big questions are?! Ian Abel Oh dear, I thought I had some conclusions. Nuno Loureiro I've got my little fingers inside this plasma. Steve Cowley Words will play a big role in this talk. Dmitri Uzdensky Everything that can be done should be done---and that's the astrophysical attitude. Michael Medvedev What I will talk about is not low-hanging fruit. A lot of people have looked at this. There is no fruit here at all.---How about sour grapes? Michael Medvedev & Nuno Loureiro In order to have a disappointment, you first have to have an appointment. Alex Schekochihin |
Wk | Date |
Time
& place |
Speaker & Topic |
Background reading |
Comings and goings (incl. visitors in town) |
Thu Jan 2 |
No seminar |
||||
-1 |
Thu Jan 9 |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma Journal Club (organised
by MICHAEL & JASON) Boozer's white paper "Stellarators as a fast path to fusion energy", arXiv:1912.06289 |
||
0 |
Thu Jan 16 |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by ALEX) Juan Ruiz Ruiz, Ollie Beeke, Valerian Chen, Nick Christen, Michael Hardman, Plamen Ivanov, Jason Parisi (Oxford) --- Possible plans for joint projects |
||
I |
Thu Jan 23, |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by ALEX) Denis St-Onge --- Update on global-local schemes |
Justin Ball (EPFL) |
|
Fri Jan 24 |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by FELIX) Justin Ball (EPFL) --- Gyrokinetic simulations a bit further out |
PoP 8, 447 (2001) arXiv:1912.09193 |
||
II |
Thu Jan 30, |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by FELIX) Open mic |
||
III |
Thu Feb 6 |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by MICHAEL) Ollie Beeke --- Attempting to recreate an internal transport barrier (ITB) with the local gyrokinetic code GS2 |
Noah Mandell (Princeton) |
|
IV |
Thu Feb 13' |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma Seminar (organised
by ALEX) Giannandrea Inchingolo (Bologna) --- Kinetic-scale effects in collisionless magnetorotational instability The magnetorotational
instability (MRI) is a crucial mechanism of angular momentum transport
in several astrophysical scenarios, like accretion disks around black
holes. The MRI has been widely studied using MHD models and
simulations, to understand the behavior of astrophysical fluids in a
state of differential rotation. In particular, the MRI plays a crucial
role in the transport of angular momentum and turbulence generation in
the late nonlinear evolution of the system. In radiatively inefficient
accretion flow (RIAF) models for accretion onto compact objects, the
accretion proceeds via a hot, low-density plasma with the proton
temperature larger than the electron temperature. To maintain the
two-temperature flow characteristic of RIAF models, the typical
collision rate must be much smaller than the accretion rate. This
suggests that the standard MHD approach may be insufficient, and a
kinetic description is required instead. Leveraging on our recent
implementation of the shearing co-rotating framework in OSIRIS 4.0, we
present our recent studies on collisionless MRI in high-beta plasma. On
sufficient large simulation domains, we observe the development of an
MRI-induced not-relativistic turbulent regime during the late nonlinear
stage of the evolution. Increasing the mass ratio of our simulations,
we show the development of enhanced ion heating during the early
nonlinear phase of collisionless MRI (channel flows regime). We will
explore the mechanism responsible for these effects. The development of
a drift-kink instability on large domains, combined with the magnetic
reconnection, is responsible for the generation of the turbulent regime
observed. The rise of an electric field during the early nonlinear
regime of the MRI acts differently on the two plasma species, inducing
the temperature difference observed in our study. We support our
assumptions with a theoretical model for kinetic compression of current
sheets, giving a quantitative prediction on the trapped particle
acceleration during the compression phase.
There will be an opportunity to interact with Giannandrea's art outreach project Turbulence: Voice of Space, in which the results presented during the seminar are explorable in virtual reality. |
ApJ 859, 149 (2018) |
Giannandrea Inchingolo (Bologna) |
V |
Thu Feb 20,' |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma Seminar (organised
by ALEX) Francois Rincon (Toulouse) --- Can high-resolution observations of solar surface convection teach us something valuable about turbulent dynamics and transport in astrophysical fluids? |
A&A 599, A69 (2017) |
Steve Cowley (Princeton) Francois Rincon (Toulouse) |
VI |
Thu Feb 27, |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma Seminar (organised
by FELIX) Peter Catto (MIT) --- Quasilinear theory: What does the delta function mean? |
JPP preprint on request |
Peter Catto (MIT) Yohei Kawazura (Tohoku U) |
VII |
Thu Mar 5 |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by MICHAEL & ALEX) Yohei Kawazura (Tohoku U) --- Update on energy partition in GK turbulence, MRI turbulence, and other stories. |
PNAS 116, 771 (2019) + new draft on request from author |
Peter Catto (MIT) Yohei Kawazura (Tohoku U) |
VIII |
Thu Mar 12 |
11:00 501 DWB |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by ALEX) Toby Adkins --- Low-beta electromagnetic plasma turbulence driven by electron-temperature gradient |
transfer report on request from Toby |
Yohei Kawazura (Tohoku U) |
9 |
Thu Mar 19 |
11:00 Teams & ZOOM |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by FELIX) Open mike: Coronavirus resultions. This will be our first virtual meeting. We will be trialling Teams and ZOOM software for it. |
||
10 |
Thu Mar 26 |
11:00 ZOOM Alex for link) |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by MICHAEL) Alex von Boetticher --- A Fokker-Planck collision model for gyrokinetic simulations in STELLArators ...followed by ZOOM lunch |
||
Thu Apr 2 |
11:00 ZOOM Alex for link) |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by FELIX) Open mike. ...followed by ZOOM lunch |
|||
Mon Apr 6 |
14:00 ZOOM (link on website) |
Virtual Nordic Dynamo Seminar (organised
by Axel Brandenburg) Denis St-Onge (Oxford) --- Fluctuation dynamo in a weakly collisional plasma |
arXiv:2003.09760 |
||
Wed Apr 7 |
16:00 ZOOM Alex or Bill for link) |
JPP Frontiers of Plasma Physics Colloquium (organised by Bill Dorland and Cary Forest) Aaron Bader (UW Madison) --- Advances in stellarator optimization Stellarators offer an
inherently steady state reactor concept with low recirculating power.
Because stellarators do not rely on plasma current for confinement,
they are not susceptible to current driven disruptions. Stellarators
are also capable of operating at high density, and can perform stably
beyond ideal MHD stability limits. Because stellarator configurations
have magnetic fields imposed mainly by external coils, there is
significant freedom to tailor the confinement properties to the device
needs. Only in the last few decades has theoretical knowledge of
stellarator confinement advanced so as to produce optimized
configurations. This talk will focus on how these devices are
optimized, both for current experiments that exist today, and for
future experiments, pilot plants, and reactor concepts. Four topical
areas, identified as key physics gaps for stellarators, are discussed:
turbulent transport optimization by design, energetic particle
transport, divertor performance, and coil design.
|
JPP 85, 905850508 (2019) |
||
Thu Apr 9 |
11:00 ZOOM Alex for link) | Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by FELIX) Juan Ruiz Ruiz --- Update on DBS work: correlation length modelling from synthetic ETG data ...followed by ZOOM lunch |
|||
-1 |
Wed Apr 15 |
16:00 ZOOM Alex or Bill for link) |
JPP Frontiers of Plasma Physics Colloquium (organised by Bill Dorland and Cary Forest) Per Helander (IPP Greifswald) --- Stellarators with permanent magnets Stellarators, tokamaks,
and other devices for fusion plasma confinement use electromagnets to
create the magnetic field. In the case of stellarators, the required
magnetic-field coils can be very complicated and contribute
significantly to the overall cost of the device. We shown that the
coils can, at least in principle, be substantially simplified by the
use of permanent magnets. Such magnets cannot create toroidal magnetic
flux, but they can be used to shape the plasma and thus to create
poloidal flux and rotational transform, thereby easing the requirements
on the magnetic-field coils. As a proof of principle, a couple of
examples of quasi-axisymmetric stellarator design with permanent
magnets are shown.
|
||
Thu Apr 16 |
11:00 ZOOM Alex for link) |
Plasma
Group Meeting (organised
by FELIX) Jason Parisi --- Update on nonlinear pedestal simulations ...followed by ZOOM lunch |