mertonlogo   physicslogo

THE OCKHAM LECTURE
The Merton College Physics Lecture


occam
Numquam ponenda est pluralitas sine necessitate
                                        
The Merton College Physics Lecture (the Ockham, or Occam, Lecture, so named in honour of one of the greatest, if unattested [1], alumni of the College and of his philosophical principle of intellectual discipline) started in 2009 and is held once a term. It is organised by the physics tutors of the College to promote both intellectual curiosity and social cohesion of the Merton Physics community. Attendance is by invitation. All Merton physicists belonging to the three Common Rooms (JCR, MCR and SCR) are invited. Their guests will also be accommodated, space permitting.

Those who are planning (or aspiring) to attend are asked to email A. Schekochihin and simultaneously to sign up for dinner in Hall in the usual manner. Also please email him if you wish to nominate a speaker for one of the future Lectures.

The Ockham (Occam) Lecture Facebook page is here. It contains photos from previous events, announcements, discussions etc., all completely unofficial but warmly encouraged. By joining the Facebook group, you will automatically receive announcements in future; you can also confirm your attendance via Facebook.

13th Lecture
Michaelmas
2013
Professor Frans Pretorius
Professor of Physics,
   Princeton University
Distinguished Research Chair,
   Perimeter Institute
Simons Investigator
webpage

Lecturer introduced by Prof James Binney FRS
TBA
TBA
Monday,
December 2
(week VIII)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
18:30 Q&A
19:15 Dinner in
Hall
12th Lecture
Trinity
2013
The 1st Ockham Debate
Professor Simon Saunders
Professor of Philosophy of Physics,
   University of Oxford
Fellow of Linacre College, Oxford
webpage
wikipedia
vs.
Professor James Binney FRS
Fellow of the College
Professor of Physics,
Director, Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics,
   University of Oxford
webpage
wikipedia

Debaters introduced and moderated by Dr Alan Barr and Dr Ralf Bader
The Problem of Quantum Measurement
Quantum mechanics is part deterministic, part probabilistic. According to the "standard" quantum theory, states evolve with certainty between measurements, but "collapse" randomly when we measure them. But what is measurement? And why does it (appear to) enjoy a privileged position in the theory? The measurement problem has been one of the hottest topics in physics ever since quantum theory was proposed and, despite much progress, remains so today. This Occam meeting will for the first time offer the different perspectives of not one but two expert speakers. Prof Saunders is a leading proponent of the "many worlds" interpretation of quantum mechanics, which argues that the Universe we see it is emergent, and constantly subject to "splitting" including during measurements. Prof Binney advocates an alternative programme, suggesting that we should gain insight into measurement by better understanding the dynamics of the system's interactions with the measuring apparatus. We anticipate a lively debate.
Monday,
May 13
(week IV)
TS Eliot LT
16:45 Reception
17:15 Debate
(Note earlier
starting time!)
19:15 Dinner in
Hall

Sign up on
Facebook

11th Lecture
Hilary
2013
Dr Anthony Hansen
Merton College (1969)
President, Magee Scientific Corporation,
   Berkeley, California
webpage
(another webpage)
Greetings from the South Pole (2.02.13)

Lecturer introduced by Prof Michael Baker
From Excitons to Soot: the Unexpected Outcome of a Physics Education
After a ‘traditional’ Ph.D. in solid-state physics, random chance led me to a newly-formed research group studying – and defining – the properties of the “soot particle.” Neither boson nor lepton, this pollutant, once considered an obsolete relic of the Coal Age, turns out to be the number-2 driver of global climate change; the number-1 driver of Arctic and Himalayan melting; and the number-1 indicator of the adverse health effects of combustion exhaust.  In addition to killing babies and submerging Florida, black particles also soil artwork, can trace the penetrability of buildings to biological attack, and can defeat directed-energy laser weapons.  The development of real-time techniques to measure ‘Black Carbon’ led to a great increase in research in these areas; to a niche business; and to field projects from Siberia to Calcutta to the South Pole.  This talk will use the above points as illustrations of how the principles of a Physics education can be applied to a “dirt” problem, with real-world consequences.
Monday,
February 25
(week VII)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
18:30 Q&A
19:15 Dinner in
Hall

Sign up on Facebook
10th Lecture
Michaelmas 2012
Professor Sir John Beddington CMG FRS
Chief Scientific Adviser to HM Goverment
Professor of Applied Population Biology,
   Imperial College London
webpage
wikipedia

Lecturer introduced by Prof Steven Cowley
Dealing with Risks and Emergencies in Government
Risk in government is pervasive. In the short term, managing emerging crises, natural or terrorist driven, involves risk assessment and dealing with an emergency in real time. At a longer time scale, risk needs to be assessed in areas including technological change, emerging diseases of humans, animals and plants and the long-term emerging issues of climate change or food, water and energy security.
Monday,
November 26
(week VIII)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
18:30 Q&A
19:15 Dinner in
Hall

Sign up on Facebook
9th Lecture
Trinity
2012
Professor Frank Arntzenius
Professor of Philosophy,
   University of Oxford
Sir Peter Strawson Fellow in Philosophy,
   University College, Oxford
webpage

Lecturer introduced by Prof Sir Ralph Wedgwood
Is the World Geometric or Algebraic?
The Ancient Greeks regarded geometry and algebra as two quite separate mathematical subjects. It was principally Fermat and Descartes who combined the two into coordinate-geometry, which since then has played an enormous role in the development of physics. I will discuss to what extent one should think that the physical structure of the world is geometric or algebraic.
Monday,
May 21
(week V)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in
Hall

Sign up on Facebook
8th Lecture
  Hilary
2012
Professor Katherine Blundell
Professor of Astrophysics,
University Research Fellow of the Royal Society,
   University of Oxford
Senior Research Fellow, St John's College, Oxford
webpage

Lecturer introduced by Prof James Binney FRS
Black Holes and Spin Offs

Monday,
January 23
(week II)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in
Hall

Sign up on
Facebook

7th Lecture
Michaelmas
2011
Professor Mark Newman
Merton College (1985)
Paul Dirac Collegiate Professor of Physics,
   University of Michigan at Ann Arbor
webpage
wikipedia

Lecturer introduced by Prof James Binney FRS
Physics in Unexpected Places: What Physics Has to Say About Social Networks, Cartography, and Space Aliens
Many ideas and techniques developed by physicists turn out to have applications outside the traditional realm of physics. In recent years physicists have made major contributions in computer science, economics, biology, and other fields. In this talk I will describe a number of projects I have worked on that fall in the general area known as "complex systems", including work on computer models of social networks, new methods for making maps based on the physics of diffusion, and a simple physical proof that could explain why we've never heard from any extraterrestrials---and why we never will.
Sunday,
October 16
(week I)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in
Savile Room
(separate sign up!)

Sign up on Facebook
6th Lecture
  Trinity
2011
Professor Sir Anthony Leggett FRS
Merton College (1958)
Honorary Fellow of the College
John and Catherine MacArthur Professor and Center for Advanced Study Professor of Physics,
   University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Nobel Prize (2003)
webpage
wikipedia

Lecturer introduced by Prof Michael Baker
Why Can't Time Run Backwards?
We can all tell when a movie of some everyday event, such as a kettle boiling or a glass shattering is run backwards. Similarly, we all feel that we can remember the past and affect the future, not vice versa. So there is a very clear "arrow" (direction) of time built into our interpretation of our everyday experience. Yet the fundamental microscopic laws of physics, be they classical or quantum-mechanical, look exactly the same if the direction of time is reversed. So what is the origin of the "arrow" of time? This is one of the deepest questions in physics; I will review some relevant considerations, but do not pretend to give a complete answer.
Friday,
May 6
(week I)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in Hall

Sign up on Facebook
5th Lecture
  Hilary
2011
Professor Persis Drell
Director,
   SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory (Stanford)
webpage
wikipedia

Lecturer introduced by Prof Andrea Cavalleri
The Turn On of LCLS: The X-Ray Free-Electron Laser at SLAC
On April 10, 2009, the world’s first hard X-ray free-electron laser was brought to lasing. Producing an X-ray beam with more than a billion times higher peak brightness than the most powerful existing synchrotron sources, it marked the beginning of a new era of science. The Linac Coherent Light Source’s (LCLS) pulses arrive at a rate of 60-120 Hz in an energy range from 480 eV to 10 keV, with pulse lengths as short as a few to about 300 femtoseconds. Since October 2009, users have been performing experiments at the LCLS. This talk will describe the LCLS and its unique new capabilities, followed by some examples of the first experiments, and finish with an outlook of future plans in the short as well as long term.
Monday,
March 7
(week VIII)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in Hall

Sign up on Facebook
4th Lecture
  Michaelmas
2010
Professor Anton Zeilinger
Professor of Experimental Physics,
   University of Vienna
Scientific Director,
   Institute of Quantum Optics and Quantum Information,
   Austrian Academy of Sciences
Wolf Prize (2010)
webpage
wikipedia
facebook

Lecturer introduced by Prof Artur Ekert
Quantum Games and Free Will
A quantum magician can play tricks that are completely impossible for any classical magician. For example, two dice rolled at an arbitrary distance will show the same number, or balls hidden under a cup can show colors impossible in any classical scenario. These are just two examples of consequences of the challenges to classical reality in the quantum world. I will show in a very instructive way how such features and others follow from the basic features of quantum physics and what they teach us about reality and free will.
Monday,
November 15
(week VI)
TS Eliot LT
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in Hall

Sign up on
Facebook

3rd Lecture
Trinity
2010

Professor Artur Ekert
Fellow of the College
Professor of Quantum Physics,
   Mathematical Institute,
University of Oxford
Lee Kong Chian Centennial Professor,
   National University of Singapore
Director, Centre for Quantum Technologies
webpage
wikipedia
facebook

Lecturer introduced by Dr Joe Fitzsimmons
Less Reality, More Security
Human desire to communicate secretly is at least as old as writing itself and goes back to the beginnings of our civilisation. Over the centuries many ingenious methods of secret communication have been developed, only to be matched by the ingenuity of code-breakers. As the result, the quest for a perfect, unbreakable, cipher, had been declared a futile pursuit. That is, until recently! Surprisingly, a combination of quantum physics and cryptography promises to dash the hopes of would-be eavesdroppers, perhaps for good. Code-makers, it seems, may have beaten code-breakers at last. In my talk I will focus on the quest for perfect secrecy. I will describe how people tried to protect communication in the past, how it is done today, and I will speculate how it may be done in the future. Physics plays increasingly more important role in this field simply because the process of sending and storing of information is always carried out by physical means. In particular, eavesdropping can be viewed as a measurement on a physical object, in this case the carrier of the information. What an eavesdropper can measure, and how, depends exclusively on the laws of physics. I will explain how, using quantum phenomena, physicists managed to design and to implement a system which is regarded to be unbreakable. Moreover, recent research shows that security of communication can be guaranteed by peculiar "non-local" correlations, no matter whether they are of quantum origin or not. Bell’s inequality alone makes seemingly insane scenario possible---devices of unknown or dubious provenance, even those that are manufactured by our enemies, can be safely used for secure communication!  I will provide a brief overview of the intriguing connections between Bell's inequality and cryptography.
    Recommended reading: semi-popular article titled "Less reality, more security"; abbreviated version published in Physics World, September 2009.
Tuesday,
May 25
(week V)
TS Eliot LT
(first ever event
in the new LT!)
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in Hall

Sign up on Facebook
2nd Lecture
Hilary
2010

Professor Lord May of Oxford FRS
Emeritus Fellow of the College
Professor, Department of Zoology,
   University of Oxford
President of the Royal Society (2000-05)
Chief Scientific Adviser to HM Government (1995-2000)
webpage
wikipedia

Lecturer introduced by Prof James Binney FRS
Systemic Risk: The Dynamics of the Banking System
The recent banking crises have made it clear that increasingly complex strategies for managing risk in individual banks and investment funds (pension funds, etc.) has not been matched by corresponding attention to overall systemic risks. Simple mathematical caricatures of “banking ecosystems”, which capture some of the essential dynamics and which have some parallels (along with significant differences) with earlier work on stability and complexity in ecological food webs, have interesting implications. In particular, strategies that tend to minimise risk for individual banks can – under certain circumstances – maximise the probability of systemic failure. This talk will first sketch these models and then discuss some of the ensuing conclusions.
Monday,
February 22
(week VI)
Mure Room
17:00 Reception
17:30 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in Hall

1st Lecture
Michaelmas
2009
Professor Steven Cowley
Director, Culham Centre for Fusion Energy
CEO, United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority
Professor of Plasma Physics,
   Imperial College London
webpage

Lecturer introduced by Dr Alex Schekochihin
Science and Technical Challenges of Fusion Power
Monday,
November 23
(week VII)
Mure Room
17:15 Reception
17:45 Lecture
19:15 Dinner in Hall



[1] Caveat: Modern historians are sceptical about William of Ockham (Occam) having been associated with Merton College, although the notion that he was does appear in a number of apocryphal or outdated sources (Warden Brodrick in his Memorials of Merton College (Clarendon Press, 1885) says that Ockham's "connection with Merton College seems to rest almost entirely on the authority of Sir Henry Savile, who cites an entry in a College MS. which [later archivists] failed to find"). While it might be argued that application of Ockham's Razor would exclude his association with Merton from the set of legitimate theoretical possibilities, it is not clear that the Razor can be legitimately applied to historical matters, as history certainly contains many unnecessary events. Some of them have never really happened and yet possess the ability to influence subsequent developments. It should also be noted in this context that whether Ockham deserves credit for the Razor is no less doubtful than whether Merton deserves credit for Ockham. What is definitely a historical fact is that the Ockham Lecture is now an ancient tradition of the College.

The image to the right is a detail of a manuscript of William of Ockham's commentary on Aristotle's Physics (MS 293 of the Merton College Library). The faces are those of some of our academic predecessors. Click on the image to see a larger version. Image courtesy of Julia Walwarth, the Fellow Librarian.
clericsMS293.jpg